Reservation
+1 218-365-7348
Visit Us
955 E Sheridan St, Ely, MN 55731, United States
Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
4 Cheese Grilled Cheese with Tomato Soup
Ala Carte
Breakfast Sandwich
Biscuits & Sausage Gravy with 2 Eggs
About
Gator's Grilled Cheese Emporium
Welcome to Gator's Grilled Cheese Emporium, a charming haven nestled in the heart of Ely, Minnesota. Located at 955 E Sheridan St, Gator's specializes in a delectable twist on the classic grilled cheese sandwich, offering an array of gourmet concoctions that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. With a reputation for both quality food and exceptional service, it's no wonder this emporium has become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
A standout on the menu is the bacon mac and cheese sandwich, celebrated for its rich, indulgent flavors. Customers like Ashley Martinson rave about this creation, which is perfect for enjoying on their spacious patio—ideal for those crisp fall days. If you're in search of something classic but elevated, the four cheese grilled cheese paired with tomato soup comes highly recommended. It's a warm, comforting combo perfect for a brisk October afternoon.
But Gator's Grilled Cheese Emporium isn’t just about the sandwiches. Reviewers like Tymbrie Snobl highlight the quick service and friendly staff, ensuring that your meal is hot and fresh, delivered within minutes. The inventive menu even features items like the turkey avocado melt and a breakfast salad, catering to various tastes and preferences. Each dish is prepared with generous portions, as noted by M A, who found their turkey bacon avocado sandwich so filling that she could only manage to finish half.
While some patrons express a wish for a broader soup selection or drink options like beer, the emphasis on quality and care in each meal at Gator's more than compensates for these minor wishes. The charming decor, pet-friendly policy, and overall inviting atmosphere make this emporium not just a place to eat, but a delightful experience to savor. For anyone visiting Ely, Gator's Grilled Cheese Emporium is a must-stop destination to indulge your palate and enjoy a friendly gathering.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The food is great and the service is quick. The bacon Mac and cheese sandwich is rich and indulgent. My husband loved it. I had the four cheese grilled cheese and tomato soup and it was perfect for a brisk but sunny October afternoon. If the weather, sit outside on their spacious patio ”
“ Owner was great came up on 2.15.25 she was most excellent highly recommend the egg with salad on grilled cheese w grain bread tomatoes basil soup was fantastic. Wish they had beers. And more soup variety. It's pricey but you leave full. We have a sheltie so we loved the decor ”
“ They don't skimp on the sandwiches. Had the turkey avocado melt, which was really good and filling. It was a short wait for food and they have patio seating. Very friendly staff. ”
“ Delicious sandwiches in a cute setting. The Turkey Bacon Avocado on Wild Rice Bread was outstanding. Large amount of REAL turkey meat, it was so filling I could only finish half. So glad I decided to try the bread, great flavor and texture. It was an unusually hot day and it was very busy but the two ladies working were trying hard to keep everyone happy. ”
“ The food was hot, fresh, delicious, and delivered within MINUTES of ordering! Erin (the waitress and breakfast cook) is friendly and available without being overbearing. The menus contain something for everyone, even with a breakfast salad (which is much more than just greens). It was so good, we had breakfast, and then came back for lunch. Definitely must eat here when visiting Ely! ”
“ This place will definitely be my go to when traveling up North! Came here because I was craving a grill cheese; I ordered the classic grill cheese with tomatoes soup; and my partner ordered the bacon mac and cheese sandwich. Both were ABSOLUTELY amazing! The bacon Mac & Cheese is a must have! It was sooo delicious and hot. The wait was relatively quick; and the waiter was extremely helpful. I also ordered a quesadilla which was pretty mediocre; I would definitely recommend having the bacon Mac & Cheese. ”
“ Can a grilled cheese sandwich get 5 stars? Yes it can. They are made absolutely perfect. Coleslaw was also really good. Would I recommend it. Yes I would. Tomato soup tasted great. Only thing I wish was that they would be more on top of refills and drinks. But besides that we will be going back. Thanks for a great sandwich. ”
“ The grilled cheese burger was so good. The coleslaw was very tasty and the chips were perfect. It is a small cozy place with great staff who were willing to chat with us seeing it was not busy at the time we were there. ”